‘æ‚R‚U”N“x–ðˆõ‹y‚Ñ‘ã‹cˆõEŒÚ–â–¼•ë
i2006”N10ŒŽ28“ú`2007”N‘‰ïj

ID–ð@ˆõ iŒhÌ—ªj
–ðE Ž@–¼ ‹Î@@@–±@@@æ í‹Î¥”ñí‹Î‚Ì•Ê
‰ï’· š¢ì@—²•v “Œ‹žH‹Æ‘åŠw@‹³Žö@‘åŠw‰@ŽÐ‰ï—HŠwŒ¤‹†‰È ”ñí‹Î
•›‰ï’· —é–؁@˜aK “d‹C’ʐM‘åŠw ‹³Žö ƒVƒXƒeƒ€HŠw‰È V
V “n糁@_”V ƒgƒˆƒ^Ž©“®ŽÔiŠ”j@‹ZŠÄ V
—Ž– r–؁@FŽ¡ ŠÖ¼‘åŠw ‹³Žö@¤Šw•” V
V ˆÀ“¡@”V—T ‹ZpŽm V
V ”Ñúœ@•q”V (à)“ú–{‹KŠi‹¦‰ï@‹³ˆçŒ¤C•”@‹³ˆçŒ¤C‰Û’· V
V Šâ“c@C“ñ ƒTƒ“ƒgƒŠ[‡Š@•iŽ¿•ÛØ–{•”ƒeƒNƒjƒJƒ‹ƒAƒhƒoƒCƒU[ V
V ‘å–ì@³’¼ “ú–{ƒKƒCƒV(Š”)@ŽQ—^ V
V ‘å“¡@@³ ‹Êì‘åŠw ‹³Žö Œo‰cŠw•” ‘ÛŒo‰cŠw‰È V
V ’·“c @ —m “Œ‹žH‹Æ‘åŠw ‹³Žö ‘åŠw‰@²ÉÍÞ°¼®ÝÏȼÞÒÝȤ‹†‰È V
V ¬‘å’Ë ˆê˜Y (à)“ú–{‰ÈŠw‹Zp˜A–¿@Ž–‹Æ•”’· V
V —é–؁@G’j ’}”g‘åŠw@•‹³Žö ‘åŠw‰@ƒVƒXƒeƒ€î•ñHŠwŒ¤‹†‰È@ V
V ’ց@”ü’qŽq “d‹C’ʐM‘åŠw •‹³Žö ƒVƒXƒeƒ€HŠw‰È V
V ‰i“c @ –õ ‘ˆî“c‘åŠw@‹³Žö@—HŠw•”Œo‰cƒVƒXƒeƒ€HŠw‰È V
V ‰iŒ´@Œ«‘¢ iŠ”jƒŠƒR[ ‹ZŽt’· Œo‰c•iŽ¿ŠÇ—–{•” V
V ªŠÝ@’B•v ƒLƒ„ƒmƒ“‡Š •iŽ¿–{•” •iŽ¿“Š‡ƒZƒ“ƒ^[ •›Š’· V
V ×’J@Ž–ç ‡‹•iŽ¿ŠÇ—‘‡Œ¤‹†Š@‘ã•\Žæ’÷–ðŠ’· V
V ¼“c@áÁˆê “ìŽR‘åŠw •‹³Žö ”—î•ñŠw•”î•ñ¼½Ãѐ”—Šw‰È V
V Œõ“¡@‹`˜Y ‚i‚t‚j‚h‡Š@’†‰›‹ZpŒ¤‹†Š@‹Zp“Š‡•”’· V
V ŽR–{@@Â “d‹C’ʐM‘åŠw uŽt ƒVƒXƒeƒ€HŠw‰È V
Šw‰ï—Ž– Š˜’J@‰À’j •xŽmƒ[ƒƒbƒNƒX‡ŠµÌ¨½ÌßÛÀ޸ϖ–{ •iŽ¿ŠÇ—•”ÏÈ°¼Þ¬° ”ñí‹Î
V ‘ë‘ò@K’j “ú–쎩“®ŽÔ‡Š@Œo‰cE•ûjŠÇ—ƒOƒ‹[ƒv ƒOƒ‹[ƒv’· V
ŠÄŽ– ŽRè@³•F Œ³@ƒRƒjƒJiŠ”j ”ñí‹Î
V _“c ”Í–¾ ¬é‘åŠw ‹³Žö ŒoÏŠw•”Œo‰cŠw‰È V

IID‘ã‹cˆõ (50‰¹‡EŒhÌ—ª@@Œv 93–¼)
Ž@–¼ ‹Î@@@–±@@@æ
H“c@^Ÿ ‡ŠƒGƒk¥ƒeƒB¥ƒeƒB¥ƒf[ƒ^ –@lËÞ¼ÞȽ„i•” Šé‰æ•”•”’·
“Vâ@Ši˜Y ÂŽRŠw‰@‘åŠw ‹³Žö —HŠw•”Œo‰c¼½ÃэHŠw‰È
ˆ»@ áÁ ˜a Œ³ ¼‰º“dŠíŽY‹ÆiŠ”j
”Ñ“c@F‹v Œcœä‹`m‘åŠw •Žè —HŠw•”ŠÇ—HŠw‰È
ˆäã@@Ë iŠ”jƒuƒŠƒaƒXƒgƒ“ •iŽ¿•ÛØ‰Û@‰Û’·
’–Œ´@³Žç ‘åã“d‹C’ʐM‘åŠw ‹³Žö î•ñ’ʐMHŠw•”@î•ñHŠw‰È
¡ˆä@t’j ƒLƒ„ƒmƒ“(Š”) •iŽ¿–{•” •iŽ¿í—ªŠé‰æ¾ÝÀ° •”’·
¡ˆä@•q”Ž ƒ\ƒj[(Š”)‚l‚r‚m‚b•iŽ¿í—ª•”@“Š‡•”’·
¡—¢@Œ’ˆê˜Y ƒPƒCEƒCƒ}ƒWƒ“@‘ã•\@
“ü‘q@‘¥•v iŠ”jƒfƒ“ƒ\[ Œo‰cŠé‰æ•” TQM„iŽº ŽåŠ²
ãŒ´@–•v “Œ–k‘åŠw ‹³Žö ‘åŠw‰@ˆãŠwŒnŒ¤‹†‰È
‘å‹÷@³Œ› (à)“ú–{•iŽ¿•ÛØ‹@\ ê–±—Ž–
‘å“c@WŒá (Š”)¬¼»ìŠ@‚m‚p|‚T„i•”@•”’·
‘å‘ê@@Œú –¾Ž¡‘åŠw ‹³Žö —HŠw•”‹@ŠBî•ñHŠw‰È
‘å–ì@@“N ƒAƒXƒ‚(Š”) •iŽ¿•ÛØ•”@•›•”’·@
‘±@L—Y ŠÖ¼“d—Í(Š”)Šé‰æŽº@•iŽ¿ŠÇ—ƒOƒ‹[ƒv@ƒ}ƒlƒWƒƒ[
‹S•@M² (Š”)“ú–{‰ÈŠw‹ZpŒ¤CŠ ”—Ž–‹Æ•” G’S“–‰Û’·
¬–ì@“¹Æ ‹Êì‘åŠw ‹³Žö HŠw•”Œo‰cHŠw‰È
¬Œ´@Dˆê ‘O“cŒšÝH‹Æ‡Š Ž·s–ðˆõ Œo‰cŠÇ—–{•” ‘‡Šé‰æ•”’·
”öŽR@‘sˆê (Š”)“ú—§»ìŠ@¿Ìijª±(Ž–)æ’[ÐÄÞÙ³ª±ŠJ”­–{•”@–{•”’·
Œ“ Žq @‹B •‘ H‹Æ‘åŠw uŽt HŠw•” ¼½Ãяî•ñHŠw‰È
‰Í‡@G‚ (à)ŠCŠO‹ZpŽÒŒ¤C‹¦‰ï “Œ‹žŒ¤CƒZƒ“ƒ^[ ŠÙ’·
ìú±@@M (Š”)ƒŠƒR[ øÉÛ¼Þ°¾ÝÀ°‰æ‘œ»•i(Ž–)@Ž–‹Æ•”’·
ìŸº@Fˆê “Œ‹žˆã‰ÈŽ•‰È‘åŠw ‹³Žö ‘åŠw‰@ˆã—ÃŒoÏŠw•ª–ì
‹e ’r @Œ’ ŒF–{‘åŠwˆãŠw•”•‘®•a‰@ •‹³Žö ˆã—Ïî•ñŒo‰cŠé‰æ•”@
–،ˁ@‹`–¾ •xŽmŽÊ^ƒtƒCƒ‹ƒ€‡Š ‚q•‚c“Š‡–{•” ‹ZpŠé‰æŽº Žå”C‹ZŽt
š àV@‰p—Y ’©“ú‘åŠw@‹³Žö Œo‰cŠw•”@Œo‰cŠw‰È
‹v•Û“c@‹œ ‡Š–L“cŽ©“®D‹@ •iŽ¿ŠÇ—•” TQM„iŽº SQC¸ÞÙ°Ìß GL
‹v•Û“c —mŽu L“‡H‹Æ‘åŠw ‹³Žö@HŠw•”@‹@ŠBƒVƒXƒeƒ€HŠw‰È
•–؁@Šw ‘åã‘åŠw@•‹³Žö ‘åŠw‰@ Šî‘bHŠwŒ¤‹†‰È
¬ŠÖ@—²•¶ “ú–{“d‹C(Š”) CSR„i–{•” CS•iŽ¿„i•” GÏÈ°¼Þ¬°
¬—с@–¾Žj ƒTƒ“ƒgƒŠ[(Š”)@•iŽ¿„i•” ‰Û’·‘㗝
¡ –ì@ ‹Î (à)“ú–{‰ÈŠw‹Zp˜A–¿@ú‘õ
Ä “¡@ ’‰ ‰ª’J“d‹@ŽY‹Æ(Š”)Œo‰c•iŽ¿Œüã¸ÞÙ°Ìß ¸ÞÙ°Ìߒ·
ŸNˆä@Œªˆê (Š”)Z—F“d‹CH‹Æ •iŽ¿ŠÇ—•” •”’·
ù•” @i “ú–{“d‹C’ʐMƒVƒXƒeƒ€(Š”) ‚b‚r•iŽ¿•ÛØ•”@•”’·
àV “c@ Œ‰ ƒRƒjƒJƒ~ƒmƒ‹ƒ^ƒrƒWƒlƒXƒGƒLƒXƒp[ƒg‡Š@•iŽ¿ŠÂ‹«ˆÀ‘S•”’·
SHANE
J.SCHVANEVELDT
WEBER STATE UNIVERSITY@DEPT.OF BUSINESS
ADMINISTRATION PROFESSOR OF MANAGEMENT
d@‹I‹` ƒ_ƒCƒLƒ“H‹Æ‡ŠŽ ‰ê»ìŠ ‹ó’²¶ŽY–{•”•iŽ¿ŠÇ—•” ’S“–•”’·
“‡@ O Žu iàj“ú–{‹KŠi‹¦‰ï —Ž–’·
“ˆú±@^m H“cŒ§—§‘åŠw y‹³Žö ƒVƒXƒeƒ€‰ÈŠw‹ZpŠw•”
´…@—Í ‚m‚s‚sƒ‰[ƒjƒ“ƒO(Š”)‘‡Œ¤C(Ž–)¿Ø­°¼®ÝËÞ¼ÞȽ„i•” •”’·
Žu‘º@Œ’ˆê —®‹…‘åŠw ‹³Žö –@•¶Šw•”
‰º“c—S‹I•v ŒQ”nH‹Æ‚“™ê–åŠwZ ‹³Žö ‹@ŠBHŠw‰È
h’J@³•v ‘å“ú–{ƒCƒ“ƒL‰»ŠwH‹Æ‡Š Ú½ÎßݼÌÞفE¹±•” •iŽ¿ŠÇ—’S“–•”’·
_‹{@‰p•v ‹à‘òH‹Æ‘åŠw ‹³Žö î•ñƒtƒƒ“ƒeƒBƒAŠw•”S—î•ñŠw‰È
—é–؁@’m“¹ “Œ‹ž—‰È‘åŠw uŽt —HŠw•”Œo‰cHŠw‰È
—é–؁@@Š° “ú–쎩“®ŽÔiŠ”j•iŽ¿•ÛØ•” •”’·
ŠÖ@ —f ˆê ŒQ”n‘åŠw@‹³Žö HŠw•”î•ñHŠw‰È@
‚‹´@•‘¥ Œcœä‹`m‘åŠw ‹³Žö ‘åŠw‰@Œ’Nƒ}ƒlƒWƒƒ“ƒgŒ¤‹†‰È
‚”¨@–¾•q Z—Fd‹@ŠBH‹ÆiŠ”jŒo‰c•iŽ¿„iŽº Žå¸
ŠÚ˜e@•¶‹I “Œ‹ž“d—Í(Š”)–{“X •iŽ¿¥ˆÀ‘SŠÄ¸•” •iŽ¿ŠÇ—“Š‡GM
“c’†@Œ’ŽŸ “d‹C’ʐM‘åŠw ‹³Žö ‘åŠw‰@î•ñ¼½ÃъwŒ¤‹†‰È
“c‘º@—T”V ÊßſƯ¸ºÐ­Æ¹°¼®Ý½Þ‡ŠµÌ¨½È¯ÄÜ°¸¶ÝÊßÆ°²‰ê •iŽ¿•ÛØG ŽåŽ–
“c ‘º@ ŠÑ ƒAƒCƒVƒ“¸‹@‡Š@TQMEPM„iŽº@•›Žº’·
“c‘º@‘וF ‡Š\‘¢‰»’mŽ¯Œ¤‹†Š@‘ã•\Žæ’÷–ð
ÀÞص ²¸µ ÐÔ¹ ƒTƒ“ƒpƒEƒ‘åŠw@HŠw•”@¶ŽYHŠw‰È
’ѐA@•qs ˆ¤’m»|iŠ”) ‘æ1¶ŽY‹Zp•” ‹Æ–±¼½ÃщüŠvG ÏÈ°¼Þ¬°
…—¬@‘Žq “Œ‹ž‘åŠw •‹³Žö@‘åŠw‰@HŠwŒnŒ¤‹†‰È@@
Ž›•”@“N‰› (à)“ú–{“K‡«”F’苦‰ï ¼½ÃєF’è•” ”F’èG’·(•”’·)
–L“‡@³s ƒuƒ‰ƒU[H‹Æ(Š”)‹Zp•”ƒeƒNƒmƒƒW[ƒZƒ“ƒ^[Gƒ}ƒl[ƒWƒƒ
’¼ˆä@’m—^ ‹Êì‘åŠw •‹³Žö HŠw•”ƒ}ƒlƒWƒƒ“ƒgƒTƒCƒGƒ“ƒXŠw‰È@
’†ˆÕ@G•q b“ì‘åŠw@‹³Žö@—HŠw•” î•ñ¼½ÃэHŠw‰È
‰iˆä@—fŽŸ “ú—§»ìŠ…ŒË‘‡•a‰@ ‰@’·
’†ì@æH•v ˆ¤’mH‹Æ‘åŠw ‹³Žö Œo‰cî•ñ‰ÈŠw•”Ï°¹Ã¨Ý¸Þî•ñŠw‰È
’†–ì@ŽŸ˜Y (Š”)ƒWƒFƒCƒeƒNƒg@Ž·s–ðˆõ
éä’J@‰À˜a iŠ”j‘º“c»ìŠ •iŽ¿ŠÇ—•”@•”’·
m‰È@@Œ’ –¼ŒÃ‰®H‹Æ‘åŠw@‚¨‚à‚Ӟæ@‹³Žö
‹´–{@‹IŽq ŠÖ¼‘åŠw ŒoÏŠw•”@‹³Žö
Œ´“c@•¶–¾ •xŽmƒ[ƒƒbƒNƒX‡Š ŠJ”­ŠÇ—–{•” ‰ðÍ‹Zp•” ƒOƒ‹[ƒv’·
•½ì@•Û”Ž “Œ‹ž—‰È‘åŠw ‹³Žö —HŠw•”Œo‰cHŠw‰È
“¡ˆä@’¨ƒ ƒTƒ“ƒfƒ“(Š”) •iŽ¿–{•”@–{•”’·
ŒÃ’J@Œ’•v ƒgƒˆƒ^Ž©“®ŽÔ(Š”)@‚s‚p‚l„i•”’·
–x“à@rK ç—tH‹ÆH‹Æ‘åŠw •‹³Žö ŽÐ‰ï¼½ÃщȊw•”
‰v“c@º•F ’é‹ž‰ÈŠw‘åŠw ‹qˆõ‹³Žö —HŠw•” ŠÂ‹«‰ÈŠw‰È@
¼‰Y@G“T ƒ_ƒCƒnƒcH‹Æ‡Š@•iŽ¿•ÛØ•”@Žå¸
¼‰Y@Œb‰î ƒIƒŠƒ“ƒpƒX(Š”) •iŽ¿•ÛØ•”
ŠÛŽR@ˆê•F •xŽR’ZŠú‘åŠw@Œo‰cî•ñŠw‰È
ŽO “‡ @–L ŽO“‡H•iiŠ”j@‘ã•\Žæ’÷–ðŽÐ’·
ŽO“c@ªŽj iàj“ú–{‰ÈŠw‹Zp˜A–¿@ê–±—Ž–EŽ––±‹Ç’·
‹{ì@‰ë–¤ “Œ‹žH‹Æ‘åŠw ‹³Žö ‘åŠw‰@ŽÐ‰ï—HŠwŒ¤‹†‰È
ŽO‘î@’q‹v ‚i‚t‚j‚h(Š”) CTOŒ“CQO ’†‰›‹ZpŒ¤‹†Š’·@í–±Žæ’÷–ð
‹{‘º@èc•v ’†‰›‘åŠw ‹³Žö —HŠw•”Œo‰cƒVƒXƒeƒ€HŠw‰È
“‹ß@‰ë•F ‘ˆî“c‘åŠw ‹³Žö —HŠw•”Œo‰cƒVƒXƒeƒ€HŠw‰È
”ªdŒû@•qs ƒgƒˆƒ^ŽÔ‘Ì(Š”) Œo‰cŠé‰æ•”@•›•”’·
”ª–؉pˆê˜Y “ŒŠC‘åŠw •‹³Žö ­Ž¡ŒoÏŠw•” Œo‰cŠw‰È
–öì@’B¶ —û”n‘‡•a‰@@“à‰È@•›‰@’·
–î–ì —FŽO˜Y “Æ—§s­–@l »•i•]‰¿‹ZpŠî”Õ‹@\ •W€‰»¾ÝÀ°’·
‰¡ŽR^ˆê˜Y •‘ H‹Æ‘åŠw ‹³Žö HŠw•”ƒVƒXƒeƒ€î•ñHŠw‰È
‹gŒ´@ß•v ‡Š“ŒŽÅ ‹ZpŠé‰æŽº@‚p‚r„iƒZƒ“ƒ^[@ŽåŠÄ
˜a“c@K•q ƒAƒCƒVƒ“EƒGƒBEƒ_ƒuƒŠƒ…iŠ”jTQM„i•” •”’·
“n糁@ˆê‰q ¬æü‘åŠw@‹³Žö@—HŠw•”@î•ñ‰ÈŠw‰È@
“n•Ó@Šì“¹ ŽR—œ‘åŠw •‹³Žö ‘åŠw‰@ˆãŠwHŠw‘‡Œ¤‹†•”

IIIDŒÚ@–⠁iŒhÌ—ªj
Ž@–¼ ‹Î@@@–±@@@æ
”ђˁ@‰xŒ÷ “Œ‹ž‘åŠw ‹³Žö@‘åŠw‰@ HŠwŒnŒ¤‹†‰È
÷ˆä@³Œõ iŠ”jƒŠƒR[ ‘ã•\Žæ’÷–ð ŽÐ’·Ž·s–ðˆõ